The Hidden Risks HR Faces When Managing Disciplinary Cases

HR Mistakes That Cost More Than You ThinkĀ 

Ā 

Every HR professional has handled a difficult case. 

  • A poor performer who can’t improve 
  • A misconduct report with no clear evidence 
  • A manager who wants to ā€œjust terminateā€ 
  • A warning letter written under pressure 

At first, it feels routine. 
Until it’s not. 

When HR Gets It Wrong, It’s Not Just a Slap on the Wrist 

In Industrial Court, a poorly handled dismissal isn’t just embarrassing. 
It can be a 6-figure payout

  • One unclear warning letter 
  • One missing Domestic Inquiry step 
  • One sentence you couldn’t justify 

That’s all it takes to lose a case. 

And once it’s lost — the damage goes beyond money: 
ā˜’ Reputational harm 
ā˜’ Morale decline 
ā˜’ Public scrutiny 
ā˜’ Internal chaos 

The Real Problem? We Learn the Law Too Late 

Most HR professionals never get formal legal training. 
They learn through: 

āŒ Trial and error 
āŒ Losing cases 
āŒ Reading court decisions after it’s too late 

But here’s the thing — employment law isn’t just legal theory. 
It’s your daily battlefield

From Managing People to Managing Liability 

Let’s be honest: 

  • How many times have you reused the same warning letter template? 
  • How confident are you that your termination process is defensible? 
  • Can you explain what makes a dismissal ā€œconstructiveā€? 

If the answer is ā€œnot sureā€ — you’re not alone. 
But it means your company is at risk every time HR acts. 

You may not have “Legal” in your job title. 
But if you: 

āœ… Issue warnings 
āœ… Draft termination letters 
āœ… Sit in grievance meetings 
āœ… Handle misconduct cases 

Then you’re already making legal decisions — whether you realise it or not. 

Final Thought 

You don’t need to become a lawyer. 
But you do need to stop guessing. 

Because in HR, what you don’t know can cost everything. 

Share the Post:

Browse more training at Malaysia’s First-Ever Training Marketplace.Ā 

Explore workshops, certification programmes and practical courses that tackle the real challenges teams face.Ā 

Disclaimer

The opinions, views, and statements expressed in this article are solely those of the author and do not reflect, represent, or constitute the official stance, policies, or positions of Malaysia HR Forum, its affiliates, or its representatives. Malaysia HR Forum makes no representations as to the accuracy, completeness, or validity of any information presented herein and shall not be liable for any errors, omissions, or any losses, injuries, or damages arising from its use. All content is provided on an “as-is” basis and is intended for informational purposes only.

Subscribe Our Newsletter